Ontological Argument

From considering the essence (essential nature) of a triangle necessarily having 3 sides, the establishment of graven image ordure be formulated. Descartes logic was first drop forward by St. Anselm, the ontological argument argues that the liking of such a existence as God necessarily entails that he lasts. The argument is as follows: I shake off an idea of God. The idea of God implies that such a being exists eternally. For this being non to exist, therefore, would entail a contradiction (a God who did non exist eternally would not be God.) Therefore, since I obviously have such an idea, this being must exist. The analogy of a bunch and valley is used. We buttocksnot believe of a mountain without a valley: the idea of a mountain necessarily entails that of a valley. Similarly, we cannot conceive of a God without the predicate of existence. However, we could conceive of both mountains and valleys not existing, implying that existence is not a predicate. Nevertheless, we cannot conceive of God without considering him as existing; the idea of God includes the idea of a being that exists. If we have a clear and distinct idea of God as a holy being (Descartes assumes we all do), wherefore God exists.




However, just because I have a perfect idea or an idea which nothing greater can be conceived, it does not entail its existence in factuality, it remains an idea. I could conjure up the thought of a crack computer, this computer is perfect and no greater computer can be conceived. Yet, the computer would cease to exist in reality, as it is merely an idea. Similarly, Gaunilo the monk disagreed with this line of argument. He replied, on behalf of the twit, with I can conceive of a most perfect and real island. Anselm states it is better to exist in the mind and in reality, this leads the fool to the conclusion that this island must exist. Gaunilo then identified the notion that a real and perfect island is absurd so he state that by association, so must be Anselms argument.If you take to get a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper